Chthonian Nightmare
Enchantment · 
Chthonian Nightmare is part of 308 combos legal in Commander. Often combined with Pitiless Plunderer and Priest of Gix.
Chthonian Nightmare
Enchantment
When this enchantment enters, you get 
(three energy counters).
Pay X , Sacrifice a creature, Return this enchantment to its owner's hand: Return target creature card with mana value X from your graveyard to the battlefield. Activate only as a sorcery.
- Mana value
- 2
- Color identity
Frequently combined with
The cards that most often join Chthonian Nightmare in its 100 most popular combos.
Combos with Chthonian Nightmare
308 combos legal in Commander.
Color Identity: B
Cards in combo:
Chthonian Nightmare
Pitiless Plunderer
Shambling Ghast
Greedy Freebooter
+1 other prerequisite
Results in combo:
Infinite creature ETB
Infinite creature LTB
Infinite death triggers
Infinite energy counters
Infinite creature sacrifice triggers
Infinite storm count
Color Identity: B
Cards in combo:
Chthonian Nightmare
Priest of Gix
Greedy Freebooter
+1 other prerequisite
Results in combo:
Infinite creature LTB
Infinite creature ETB
Infinite creature sacrifice triggers
Infinite death triggers
Infinite scry 1
Infinite storm count
Infinite energy counters
Color Identity: B
Cards in combo:
Chthonian Nightmare
Priest of Gix
Pitiless Plunderer
+2 other prerequisites
Results in combo:
Infinite artifact ETB
Infinite artifact LTB
Infinite artifact sacrifice triggers
Infinite artifact tokens
Infinite creature LTB
Infinite creature ETB
Infinite colored mana
Infinite creature sacrifice triggers
Infinite death triggers
Infinite storm count
Infinite Treasure tokens
Infinite energy counters
Color Identity: B
Cards in combo:
Chthonian Nightmare
Priest of Gix
Shambling Ghast
+1 other prerequisite
Results in combo:
Infinite creature LTB
Infinite creature ETB
Infinite creature sacrifice triggers
Infinite death triggers
Infinite storm count
Infinite energy counters
Color Identity: B, R
Cards in combo:
Chthonian Nightmare
Priest of Gix
Priest of Urabrask
+1 other prerequisite
Results in combo:
Infinite black mana
Infinite death triggers
Infinite creature ETB
Infinite creature LTB
Infinite red mana
Infinite creature sacrifice triggers
Infinite storm count
Color Identity: B
Cards in combo:
Chthonian Nightmare
Greedy Freebooter
Shambling Ghast
Jet Medallion
Results in combo:
Infinite creature LTB
Infinite creature ETB
Infinite creature sacrifice triggers
Infinite death triggers
Infinite scry 1
Infinite storm count
Infinite energy counters
Color Identity: B
Cards in combo:
Chthonian Nightmare
Pawn of Ulamog
Shambling Ghast
Greedy Freebooter
+1 other prerequisite
Results in combo:
Infinite creature LTB
Infinite creature ETB
Infinite creature sacrifice triggers
Infinite death triggers
Infinite storm count
Infinite energy counters
Color Identity: B
Cards in combo:
Pitiless Plunderer
Wriggling Grub
Chthonian Nightmare
Viscera Seer
Results in combo:
Infinite artifact ETB
Infinite artifact LTB
Infinite artifact sacrifice triggers
Infinite artifact tokens
Infinite creature LTB
Infinite creature ETB
Infinite creature sacrifice triggers
Infinite death triggers
Infinite scry 1
Infinite storm count
Infinite creature tokens
Infinite energy counters
Infinite colored mana
Infinite Treasure tokens
Color Identity: B, R
Cards in combo:
Chthonian Nightmare
Impulsive Pilferer
Pitiless Plunderer
Greedy Freebooter
+1 other prerequisite
Results in combo:
Infinite creature ETB
Infinite creature LTB
Infinite death triggers
Infinite energy counters
Infinite creature sacrifice triggers
Infinite storm count
Color Identity: B
Cards in combo:
Wriggling Grub
Chthonian Nightmare
Phyrexian Altar
Results in combo:
Infinite creature LTB
Infinite creature ETB
Infinite creature sacrifice triggers
Infinite death triggers
Infinite storm count
Infinite energy counters
Color Identity: B
Cards in combo:
Pitiless Plunderer
Wriggling Grub
Chthonian Nightmare
Ashnod's Altar
Results in combo:
Infinite artifact ETB
Infinite artifact LTB
Infinite artifact sacrifice triggers
Infinite artifact tokens
Infinite creature LTB
Infinite creature ETB
Infinite creature sacrifice triggers
Infinite death triggers
Infinite colorless mana
Infinite storm count
Infinite creature tokens
Infinite energy counters
Infinite colored mana
Infinite Treasure tokens
Color Identity: B
Cards in combo:
Pitiless Plunderer
Wriggling Grub
Chthonian Nightmare
Carrion Feeder
Results in combo:
Infinite artifact ETB
Infinite artifact LTB
Infinite artifact sacrifice triggers
Infinite artifact tokens
Infinite creature LTB
Infinite creature ETB
Infinite creature sacrifice triggers
Infinite death triggers
Infinite storm count
Infinite creature tokens
Infinite +1/+1 counters on a creature
Infinite energy counters
Infinite colored mana
Infinite Treasure tokens
Color Identity: B, R
Cards in combo:
Chthonian Nightmare
Priest of Gix
Skittering Precursor
Ashnod's Altar
+1 other prerequisite
Results in combo:
Infinite creature LTB
Infinite creature ETB
Infinite creature sacrifice triggers
Infinite death triggers
Infinite colorless mana
Infinite storm count
Infinite black mana
Color Identity: B, R
Cards in combo:
Chthonian Nightmare
Impulsive Pilferer
Greedy Freebooter
Skittering Precursor
+1 other prerequisite
Results in combo:
Infinite creature LTB
Infinite creature ETB
Infinite creature sacrifice triggers
Infinite death triggers
Infinite storm count
Infinite energy counters
Color Identity: W, B
Cards in combo:
Chthonian Nightmare
Pitiless Plunderer
Mondrak, Glory Dominus
+1 other prerequisite
Results in combo:
Infinite artifact ETB
Infinite artifact LTB
Infinite artifact sacrifice triggers
Infinite creature ETB
Infinite creature LTB
Infinite death triggers
Infinite energy counters
Infinite creature sacrifice triggers
Infinite storm count
Color Identity: B, R
Cards in combo:
Chthonian Nightmare
Priest of Gix
Skittering Precursor
Viscera Seer
+1 other prerequisite
Results in combo:
Infinite creature LTB
Infinite creature ETB
Infinite creature sacrifice triggers
Infinite death triggers
Infinite scry 1
Infinite storm count
Infinite black mana
Color Identity: B, R
Cards in combo:
Chthonian Nightmare
Impulsive Pilferer
Pitiless Plunderer
Shambling Ghast
+1 other prerequisite
Results in combo:
Infinite creature ETB
Infinite creature LTB
Infinite death triggers
Infinite energy counters
Infinite creature sacrifice triggers
Infinite storm count
Color Identity: B, R
Cards in combo:
Chthonian Nightmare
Shambling Ghast
Greedy Freebooter
Skittering Precursor
+1 other prerequisite
Results in combo:
Infinite creature LTB
Infinite creature ETB
Infinite creature sacrifice triggers
Infinite death triggers
Infinite storm count
Infinite energy counters
Color Identity: B, R
Cards in combo:
Chthonian Nightmare
Impulsive Pilferer
Shambling Ghast
Skittering Precursor
+1 other prerequisite
Results in combo:
Infinite creature LTB
Infinite creature ETB
Infinite creature sacrifice triggers
Infinite death triggers
Infinite storm count
Infinite energy counters
Color Identity: B, R
Cards in combo:
Chthonian Nightmare
Priest of Gix
Skittering Precursor
Phyrexian Altar
+1 other prerequisite
Results in combo:
Infinite creature LTB
Infinite creature ETB
Infinite colored mana
Infinite creature sacrifice triggers
Infinite death triggers
Infinite storm count
